[Podcast Episode #36] The Elevator Pitch: How to Say What You Do and Make People Lean In
Episode #36
Most elevator pitches don’t fail because they’re too short. They fail because they’re trying to be a brochure. In this episode we share a better goal that instantly changes how you introduce yourself: spark real curiosity, then earn the next conversation.
Some topics covered are:
- Turning darkness into beauty on Medici Day
- Curiosity-driven elevator pitches
- Letting others lead to find common ground
- Avoiding desperation in first impressions
- Posture, presence, and composure
- Choosing relevance over feature dumping
- Leading with who you are
- Being remembered through humanity and humor
- Timing, silence, and situational awareness
- Cultural awareness in networking
- Storytelling over technical facts
- And more…
Episode Summary
Most people think an elevator pitch is about squeezing more words into less time. They rehearse their features, polish their title, and prepare to prove why their business matters. But the real problem is not that people say too little. It is that they say too much before anyone is curious enough to care.
Turn The Dark Into Beautiful
Cris opened with a story from Berlin, where a Medici Day was hosted inside a former Nazi bunker that had been transformed into a private art collection. The building once held thousands of people in fear. Now it holds beauty, culture, and the work of living artists.
It was more than an interesting location. It became an image for business and life. Some things begin in darkness, but with vision, cost, and care, they can become something beautiful. That same principle applies to the way we present ourselves. A pitch does not need to be loud or polished to impress. It needs to reveal that something meaningful is there.
Curiosity Is The Goal
Cris described the elevator pitch as a short window. You step into a brief moment with another person, and you have only enough time to create interest. The goal is not to explain everything. The goal is curiosity.
This is where many people lose the room. They answer “What do you do?” with a long list of technical details, services, products, and features. Within seconds, the other person is looking for the exit. A better pitch makes someone lean in. It leaves them thinking, “There is more to this person.”
Let The Other Person Go First
Philip brought the conversation back to listening. A pitch is not only about what you say. It is shaped by what you hear first. When the other person speaks before you, they often give you the clues you need to make a real connection.
Cris agreed. Letting the other person go first is polite, but it is also practical. You may discover shared geography, values, problems, or interests. Then your response is not generic. It is connected to the person in front of you. That is the difference between a pitch and a conversation.
Desperation Has A Smell
Philip called it “commission breath.” It is the feeling people get when someone is not really interested in them, only in the deal. Cris named the deeper issue: desperation.
When someone tries too hard to impress, convince, close, or prove themselves, people pull back. Desperation makes even good words feel unsafe. A strong first impression is not frantic. It is composed. It carries confidence without pressure.
Posture Speaks Before Words
Cris argued that an elevator pitch is more posture than language. Before people process your explanation, they notice how you enter the room, how you stand, how you dress, how you make eye contact, and how you shake a hand.
Philip admitted that appearance can feel uncomfortable to talk about because we want character to matter more. But people often decide whether they will listen before they ever see your character. The outside is not everything, but it can either open or close the door to what is inside.
Lead With The Person, Not The Product
One of Cris’s strongest principles was simple: talk first about who you are, not what you sell. People buy into the person before they buy into the business.
That does not mean oversharing or forcing vulnerability into every conversation. It means showing humanity. A small story, a moment of humor, or an honest glimpse of failure can make you memorable. Cris talked about using stories from his family when speaking publicly because they made people laugh, remember him, and see him as human before they heard his ideas.
Stories Create Connection
Technical facts rarely create connection on their own. Cris described meeting businesspeople who immediately dive into complicated industry language. The problem is not that they lack value. The problem is that nobody outside their world knows how to enter the conversation.
A story gives people a door. It turns abstract work into something they can see and feel. The best elevator pitch does not dump information. It creates a moment where another person wants to know more.
In Conclusion
In the end, the elevator pitch is not a script to memorize. It is the art of showing up with enough confidence, humanity, and restraint that someone else becomes curious enough to stay.
Get a free copy of "Get Your House in Order"
Principles of success based on the life of Cosimo de’ Medici by Cris Auditore Zimmermann